Chances of Getting Audited by CRA: Key Factors and Statistics

A woman conducting a CRA Audit at a counter in a store.

Chances of Getting Audited by CRA: Key Factors and Statistics

Sebastien Prost, CPA

Facing an audit by the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) can be an intimidating prospect for many taxpayers. Each year, the CRA conducts audits to ensure compliance with the tax laws and to verify the accuracy of the information provided in tax filings. While many may believe that audits are entirely random, there are in fact certain red flags and triggers that increase the likelihood of being selected for an audit. It’s important for individuals and businesses alike to understand these indicators, as awareness and proper tax practices can reduce the risk of drawing unwanted attention from the CRA.

Some common triggers include significant discrepancies between reported income and lifestyle, errors or inconsistencies in submitted tax returns, and claiming deductions that are unusually high compared to others in similar financial situations. The CRA also pays close attention to self-employed individuals and businesses that conduct a large number of cash transactions. Moreover, those with a history of previous audits or adjustments may be more likely to be audited again.

However, not all audits are the result of red flags; some are indeed selected at random. It is estimated that a small percentage of corporations and individuals are audited each year on this basis. Being prepared and having transparent records can mitigate the stress and potential complications that come with being audited, whether it is random or triggered by specific concerns of the CRA.

Overview of CRA Audits

The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) conducts audits to verify compliance with tax laws. By understanding what triggers an audit and recognizing the risk factors, taxpayers can better prepare and reduce the chances of being audited.

What Triggers a CRA Audit?

An audit by the CRA can be initiated through various means:

  • Random Selection: The CRA employs a risk assessment model which occasionally selects tax returns at random.
  • Tips from Third Parties: Information provided by external sources about potential non-compliance or fraudulent activity.

Risk Factors for Small Businesses

Small businesses should be aware of certain activities that might increase the risk of an audit:

  • Discrepancies in Filed Returns: Inconsistencies between different tax forms or with industry norms.
  • High Expense Claims: Large deductions for vehicle, home office, or business expenses that are unusually high for the business type.

Statistical Likelihood of Being Audited

While the overall likelihood of an audit is relatively low, certain factors may elevate a business’s risk:

  • Income Level: Businesses with significantly higher or lower income than average may be flagged.
  • Lifestyle incongruity: Income reported is not in line with the taxpayer’s lifestyle or assets.
  • Type of Deductions: Uncommon deductions or large charitable donations can draw attention.

CRA Audit Process

The CRA Audit Process involves meticulous examination of an individual’s or business’s financial records to ensure compliance with tax laws. This process includes several stages and the use of varied techniques to assess the accuracy of tax returns.

Stages of a CRA Audit

A CRA audit typically commences with an initial contact by the agency and progresses through various stages. The first stage is the Selection, where a tax file may be chosen for audit due to random selection, comparison against norms, or as a result of information obtained from third-party sources. Following this, the Review and Planning stage involves the auditor developing a tailored audit plan based on the risks or issues identified.

Then comes the Execution stage, during which the CRA conducts a thorough investigation of the taxpayer’s records. If discrepancies are found, a proposal letter will be issued with the auditor’s findings. The auditor will give the taxpayer 30 days to respond and refute the auditor’s findings if they choose to do so. After the proposal stage, the auditor sends out their final letter along with a notice of reassessment, if applicable.

Documentation and Information Requests

Throughout the audit process, taxpayers will receive official requests for information. These requests can include income statements, receipts, books, records, bank statements or any other documents necessary to verify the accuracy of the filed tax returns. The CRA generally specifies a response deadline, and it is critical for taxpayers to comply with these requests to ensure a smooth audit process.

If the taxpayer does not provide all banking information, the auditor also has the ability to request them directly from financial institutions through requirements for information (RFIs). This is permitted under section 231.2 of the Income Tax Act and makes it mandatory for banks to provide CRA with all financial information requested.

CRA Audit Techniques

The CRA employs a combination of techniques during an audit. Comparative Analysis involves reviewing a taxpayer’s data against similar tax filers’ information. Direct Audit Methods may be used where auditors directly examine books, records, and supporting documentation. As indicated in Chapter 13.3.1 of the CRA Audit Manual, the CRA may opt to use Indirect Verification of Income (IVI) audit techniques when assessing the overall financial situation of a taxpayer to identify discrepancies between reported income and lifestyle indicating unreported income. IVI usually includes a bank deposit analysis, where all deposits made to all of the taxpayer’s personal bank account are compared with the income reported on their personal tax return.

Reducing the Risk of an Audit

When it comes to reducing the risk of a Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) audit, certain practices can make a difference. These include accurate and timely tax filing, maintaining comprehensive records, and seeking the expertise of a professional accountant.

Accurate and Timely Filing

Accuracy in tax returns is critical. One should ensure that all income is reported, and calculations are double-checked to avoid discrepancies that might flag the CRA’s attention. Timely filing of tax returns is equally important. Late submissions can increase scrutiny and the likelihood of an audit.

  • File on Time: Every tax year, returns should be filed by the due date to avoid late-filing penalties and potential audits.
  • Report All Income: Failing to report income can lead to reassessments and interest charges, along with a higher chance of being audited.
  • Use a Cloud Accounting Software: Cloud accounting software such as Xero allow you to easily store all tax relevant documentation in the cloud. This can then be quickly accessed in case of a CRA audit.

Keeping Detailed Records

One should keep detailed records of all financial transactions. Receipts, invoices, and documents related to income and deductions should be meticulously filed and readily accessible. If the CRA requests supporting documentation, a taxpayer must be able to produce it promptly.

  • Organize Documents: Maintain well-organized records for at least six years, which is the period during which the CRA can audit returns.

Hiring a Professional Accountant

Professional accountants can help navigate the complexities of tax laws, ensuring compliance and minimizing the likelihood of errors that could result in an audit. They are trained to understand the nuances of bookkeeping and tax preparation, which can act as a preventive measure against potential audits.

  • Expertise: A professional accountant can provide valuable advice on tax planning and help prepare a tax return that complies with all regulations.
  • Representation: If audited, an accountant can represent the taxpayer before the CRA, offering expert guidance through the process.

Consequences of a CRA Audit

When the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) conducts an audit, the taxpayer is subject to a thorough review that can lead to various repercussions. These include adjustments to tax returns, imposition of interest and penalties, and potential legal actions.

Potential Outcomes of an Audit

An audit by the CRA can lead to several potential outcomes for a taxpayer. If discrepancies are found, the CRA may adjust the tax returns to accurately reflect the taxpayer’s obligations. This can result in additional taxes owed if it is determined that the taxpayer underreported income or overstated deductions. Conversely, if the audit finds that the taxpayer overpaid, they may receive a refund. It should also be noted that if no issues are uncovered, the CRA will not make any changes to the filed tax returns.

Penalties and Fines

The CRA may levy penalties and fines on taxpayers if the audit uncovers intentional misrepresentations or severe negligence. The penalties can be substantial, sometimes amounting to more than the additional tax owed. For example, a gross negligence penalty can be as high as 50% of the understated tax and/or the overstated credits related to the false statement or omission.

Dispute Resolution Options

After the completion of an audit, if taxpayers disagree with the audit conclusions, they have the option to dispute the findings. They can file an objection, which will prompt an internal review of the decision made during the audit. Should they remain dissatisfied with the outcome after exercising this option, they may take their case to the Tax Court of Canada for an independent judgment. It’s important for taxpayers to act in a timely manner, as there are strict deadlines for filing objections.

Taxpayer Rights and Responsibilities

The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) upholds a Taxpayer Bill of Rights that guarantees fair treatment and transparent processes. Taxpayers, simultaneously, must adhere to tax laws and fulfill their financial obligations accurately.

Rights During an Audit

Taxpayers in Canada are entitled to a set of rights during the audit process. Key rights include:

  • Accuracy and Professionalism: Taxpayers can expect the CRA to conduct audits with high standards of accuracy and professionalism.
  • Courteousness and Fairness: Interaction with the CRA should be courteous and equitable, respecting the dignity of taxpayers.
  • Informed: Individuals have the right to be informed about the audit process and the particular areas of review.
  • Representation: One may choose to be represented by a person of their choosing during their dealings with the CRA.

Your Obligations Under the Tax Law

Taxpayers are responsible for a number of obligations under Canadian tax law, which include:

  • Accuracy of Submissions: Taxpayers must accurately report all income and claim only the credits and deductions to which they are legally entitled.
  • Record Keeping: They are obligated to maintain proper books and records as required by law.
  • Compliance with Deadlines: It is their duty to honor all tax deadlines for returns and payments.
  • Cooperation During Audits: When selected for an audit, taxpayers are expected to provide the information and documents requested by the CRA in a timely manner.

Audit Trends and Changes

In response to the ever-evolving nature of tax compliance, the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) not only adapts its audit focus areas but also modifies its audit activities to improve efficiency and effectiveness.

Current CRA Focus Areas

  • High-Income Taxpayers: The CRA continues to direct attention towards individuals with higher income levels or complex financial structures, deeming them more likely to participate in aggressive tax avoidance.
  • Net Worth Assessments: Taxpayers who report low income or losses even and who live a lifestyle who cannot be supported by that level of income.
  • Gig Economy: Increased scrutiny on the gig economy ensures that income from such activities is correctly reported.
  • Real Estate Transactions: Specific attention is given to real estate transactions due to the potential for unreported capital gains and related taxes. Short-term rentals such as AirBNBs have also been a CRA target in recent years.
  • International Transactions: With globalization, the CRA emphasizes the importance of transparency in cross-border transactions and compliance with international tax obligations.

Recent Changes in Audit Activity

  • Enhanced Data Analytics: The CRA has integrated more sophisticated data analytics to pinpoint non-compliance, thereby making audit processes more targeted.
  • Outreach Initiatives: Audit activities now include educational outreach to help taxpayers understand their obligations before any discrepancies arise.

By focusing on these specific areas and adapting their approach, the CRA aims to maintain compliance and fairness in the tax system.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) conducts audits to ensure compliance with tax laws. Understanding what triggers an audit and how the process works can help taxpayers prepare and respond appropriately.

What factors increase the risk of being selected for a CRA audit?

Certain activities can raise red flags with the CRA, such as discrepancies between income and HST filings, aggressive tax planning, repeated losses from a business, or large charitable donations. Taxpayers who are self-employed or have complex tax situations may also be more susceptible to audits.

How many years back does the CRA typically review when conducting an audit?

The CRA usually has the authority to audit tax returns within three years of the original notice of assessment. However, if there is a suspicion of fraud or misrepresentation, the CRA can go back further.

What are the common reasons for receiving a CRA audit letter?

Common reasons for an audit include inconsistencies in reported income, claiming substantially higher deductions or credits than similar taxpayers, or previous audits resulting in a reassessment. Also, random selection plays a role in determining who will be audited.

What kind of support can I expect during a CRA audit process?

During an audit, the CRA provides a clear outline of the process, the information needed, and the auditor’s contact details. Taxpayers have the right to professional representation and are encouraged to ask questions and seek clarification at any point.

How frequently does the CRA conduct payroll audits?

Payroll audits do not follow a regular schedule and can be conducted at any time. Employers should maintain accurate payroll records to ensure they can substantiate all amounts reported to the CRA.

What steps should I take if I am contacted by the CRA for an audit?

If contacted for an audit, taxpayers should review the audit letter carefully, gather all relevant documentation, and may consider seeking professional advice. Promptly responding to CRA requests and maintaining open communication are critical steps in the audit process.

Sebastien Prost, CPA

Written by Sebastien Prost, CPA

Seb Prost, a CPA with over 10 years of experience in taxation and accounting, offers a unique blend of insights from his time at the CRA and his experience in public practice. Originally from QC and now based in Nelson, BC, he specializes in guiding Canadian startups, SaaS companies and other online businesses for all of their accounting and taxation needs.

Looking for an Accounting Partner for your Business?

You May Also Like…